Shortstops and Defensive Win Shares

December 09, 2004

A review at Batter’s Box

The outstanding Blue Jays’ blog, battersbox.ca, has a nice review of shortstops by Mike Green. Mike and the pursuant commentators do a particularly good job of discussing the measurement of a shortstop’s fielding impact.

Bill James put boundaries on fielding Win Shares, at both the team and individual player, because he didn’t fully trust the output (I think).  This makes it hard to use fielding Win Shares to evaluate really good (and bad) fielders in any given year or career.  This is a significant issue that should be kept in mind when discussing some of the great ones, like Ozzie Smith.



<<Previous Article:  Win Shares Replacement Level Next Article:  Re Re Placement Levels>>