“Morgan and Those Who Followed”

January 12, 2004

An excellent analysis of Joe Morgan’s career, including some very good insights regarding some Win Shares’ limitations.

At the excellent Toronto Blue Jays’ site, Batters Box, Robert Dudek has posted a review of Joe Morgan’s career, using Win Shares as his criterion.

I particularly like some of Robert’s modifiers, which address some of the Win Share issues we’ve talked about on this site:

- A seeming bias against starting pitchers, which we’ve taken some steps to address.
- An issue in leagues with the designated hitter.  I’ve suggested some steps to address this issue, such as the Win Shares baseline, crediting pitchers and batters with negative Win Shares when warranted, and pulling pitchers’ batting Win Shares out into the open.  These may not be enough to address the DH problem, however.  I need to do some more research.
- A historic issue in strike-shortened seasons, when evaluating player’s careers (which I hadn’t thought about).

Robert also talks about the use of Win Shares replacement level, which I hope to address as a continuation of the Win Shares baseline concept.  A great article.



Something Robert missed, but there is a wholly non-arbitrary way to measure peak performance. It’s the square root of the sum of the squares of each individual year’s Win Shares. I like to divide those individual squares by the expected Win Shares, but either way, it ensures a player who earns 20 WS one year and 10 the next rates better than the player who earns 15 WS in each year.

Posted by .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)  on  01/13  at  03:34 PM
Page 1 of 1 pages
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.
<<Previous Article:  The Best Players In Baseball 2004 Next Article:  DER Responsibility>>