AL Batting WSAA Rankings

November 15, 2003

Doh! I made a mistake, so here's a list of the top ten AL Batting Win Shares Above Average leaders (updated as of the 18th):

Name Team Win Shares Game Shares WSAA
C Delgado TOR 30.9 21.5 20.2
M Ramirez BOS 25.5 19.9 15.6
J Giambi NYY 26.1 22.3 14.9
A Rodriguez TEX 27.0 25.5 14.2
F Thomas CWS 22.7 19.7 12.8
E Martinez SEA 19.6 16.1 11.6
C Beltran KC 22.2 21.3 11.5
B Boone SEA 21.5 21.4 10.9
G Anderson ANA 22.6 23.7 10.8
J Posada NYY 20.4 19.7 10.6


And here's a link to all AL batting WSAA holders, ranked within team.

You can see how the WSAA rankings differ significantly from the WS rankings.  Look at KC, for instance.  Raul Ibanez created 12.2 batting Win Shares, but zero WSAA.  On the other hand, Mike Sweeney created 14.4 and 6.2.  KC followers probably knew that Sweeny added more value than Ibanez, despite his limited playing time, and now Win Shares reflects that.

Another example: Edgar Martinez and Brett Boone switched leader positions on the Mariners, thanks to Edgar’s much-lower out rate.

There’s a lot you can do with this data.  For instance, if you feel that an appropriate replacement level is 80%, you can multiply the Game Shares by 40% to compute the batting Win Shares above replacement level.  You may want to compute different replacement levels for different positions and different leagues.  Go nuts.



<<Previous Article:  Batting Game Shares Next Article:  NL Batting WSAA Rankings>>