Historical Gold Glove/Win Share Comparison

November 06, 2003

I ran a quick comparison of the Gold Glove winners with the defensive win share leaders.  Since 1961, 237 of the 689 Gold Glove winners were the leaders their position in defensive win shares.

(Why 1961?  Before then, individual Gold Gloves were given to each of the three outfield positions, LF, CF, and RF.  Starting in 1961, the outfield Gold Gloves were given to any three outfielders, regardless of position.)

Year….League..Pos…..Gold Glove….......Win Share Leader
1961….AL…...C…....Earl Battey…......Earl Battey
1962….AL…...C…....Earl Battey…......Earl Battey
1963….AL…...C…....Elston Howard…....Earl Battey
1964….AL…...C…....Elston Howard…....Elston Howard
1965….AL…...C…....Bill Freehan….....Bill Freehan
1966….AL…...C…....Bill Freehan….....Bill Freehan
1967….AL…...C…....Bill Freehan….....Bob Rodgers
1968….AL…...C…....Bill Freehan….....Bill Freehan
1969….AL…...C…....Bill Freehan….....Bill Freehan
1970….AL…...C…....Ray Fosse…........George Mitterwald
1971….AL…...C…....Ray Fosse…........Bill Freehan
1972….AL…...C…....Carlton Fisk….....Ed Herrmann
1973….AL…...C…....Thurman Munson…...Thurman Munson
1974….AL…...C…....Thurman Munson…...Glenn Borgmann
1975….AL…...C…....Thurman Munson…...Brian Downing
1976….AL…...C…....Jim Sundberg….....Jim Sundberg
1977….AL…...C…....Jim Sundberg….....Jim Sundberg
1978….AL…...C…....Jim Sundberg….....Jim Sundberg
1979….AL…...C…....Jim Sundberg….....Jim Sundberg
1980….AL…...C…....Jim Sundberg….....Rick Cerone
1981….AL…...C…....Jim Sundberg….....Jim Sundberg
1982….AL…...C…....Bob Boone…........Bob Boone
1983….AL…...C…....Lance Parrish…....Lance Parrish
1984….AL…...C…....Lance Parrish…....Lance Parrish
1985….AL…...C…....Lance Parrish…....Bob Boone
1986….AL…...C…....Bob Boone…........Rich Gedman
1987….AL…...C…....Bob Boone…........Ernie Whitt
1988….AL…...C…....Bob Boone…........Andy Allanson
1989….AL…...C…....Bob Boone…........Bob Boone
1990….AL…...C…....Sandy Alomar Jr…..Lance Parrish
1991….AL…...C…....Tony Pena…........Lance Parrish
1992….AL…...C…....Ivan Rodriguez…...Ivan Rodriguez
1993….AL…...C…....Ivan Rodriguez…...Ron Karkovice
1994….AL…...C…....Ivan Rodriguez…...Terry Steinbach
1995….AL…...C…....Ivan Rodriguez…...Ivan Rodriguez
1996….AL…...C…....Ivan Rodriguez…...Ivan Rodriguez
1997….AL…...C…....Ivan Rodriguez…...Ivan Rodriguez
1998….AL…...C…....Ivan Rodriguez…...Ivan Rodriguez
1999….AL…...C…....Ivan Rodriguez…...Ivan Rodriguez
2000….AL…...C…....Ivan Rodriguez…...Brad Ausmus
2001….AL…...C…....Ivan Rodriguez…...Einar Diaz
2002….AL…...C…....Bengie Molina…....Bengie Molina
2003….AL…...C…....Bengie Molina…....Ramon Hernandez
1961….NL…...C…....Johnny Roseboro…..Johnny Roseboro
1962….NL…...C…....Del Crandall….....Johnny Edwards
1963….NL…...C…....Johnny Edwards…...Johnny Edwards
1964….NL…...C…....Johnny Edwards…...Johnny Edwards
1965….NL…...C…....Joe Torre…........Tom Haller
1966….NL…...C…....Johnny Roseboro…..Johnny Roseboro
1967….NL…...C…....Randy Hundley…....Tim McCarver
1968….NL…...C…....Johnny Bench….....Johnny Bench
1969….NL…...C…....Johnny Bench….....Randy Hundley
1970….NL…...C…....Johnny Bench….....Johnny Bench
1971….NL…...C…....Johnny Bench….....Manny Sanguillen
1972….NL…...C…....Johnny Bench….....Duffy Dyer
1973….NL…...C…....Johnny Bench….....Joe Ferguson
1974….NL…...C…....Johnny Bench….....Johnny Bench
1975….NL…...C…....Johnny Bench….....Steve Yeager
1976….NL…...C…....Johnny Bench….....Johnny Bench
1977….NL…...C…....Johnny Bench….....Gary Carter
1978….NL…...C…....Bob Boone…........Gary Carter
1979….NL…...C…....Bob Boone…........Gary Carter
1980….NL…...C…....Gary Carter…......Gary Carter
1981….NL…...C…....Gary Carter…......Gary Carter
1982….NL…...C…....Gary Carter…......Gary Carter
1983….NL…...C…....Tony Pena…........Gary Carter
1984….NL…...C…....Tony Pena…........Tony Pena
1985….NL…...C…....Tony Pena…........Gary Carter
1986….NL…...C…....Jody Davis….......Jody Davis
1987….NL…...C…....Mike LaValliere…..Mike Scioscia
1988….NL…...C…....Benito Santiago…..Tony Pena
1989….NL…...C…....Benito Santiago…..Mike Scioscia
1990….NL…...C…....Benito Santiago…..Darren Daulton
1991….NL…...C…....Tom Pagnozzi….....Tom Pagnozzi
1992….NL…...C…....Tom Pagnozzi….....Joe Oliver
1993….NL…...C…....Kirt Manwaring…...Rick Wilkins
1994….NL…...C…....Tom Pagnozzi….....Joe Girardi
1995….NL…...C…....Charles Johnson…..Joe Girardi
1996….NL…...C…....Charles Johnson…..Charles Johnson
1997….NL…...C…....Charles Johnson…..Charles Johnson
1998….NL…...C…....Charles Johnson…..Javy Lopez
1999….NL…...C…....Mike Lieberthal…..Mike Lieberthal
2000….NL…...C…....Mike Matheny….....Mike Matheny
2001….NL…...C…....Brad Ausmus…......Brad Ausmus
2002….NL…...C…....Brad Ausmus…......Brad Ausmus
2003….NL…...C…....Mike Matheny….....Brian Schneider
1961….AL…...1B…...Vic Power…........Norm Cash
1962….AL…...1B…...Vic Power…........Norm Cash
1963….AL…...1B…...Vic Power…........Norm Cash
1964….AL…...1B…...Vic Power…........Norm Cash
1965….AL…...1B…...Joe Pepitone….....Norm Cash
1966….AL…...1B…...Joe Pepitone….....Norm Cash
1967….AL…...1B…...George Scott….....Harmon Killebrew
1968….AL…...1B…...George Scott….....Tom McCraw
1969….AL…...1B…...Joe Pepitone….....Don Mincher
1970….AL…...1B…...Jim Spencer…......Mike Hegan
1971….AL…...1B…...George Scott….....Jim Spencer
1972….AL…...1B…...George Scott….....Dick Allen
1973….AL…...1B…...George Scott….....John Mayberry
1974….AL…...1B…...George Scott….....George Scott
1975….AL…...1B…...George Scott….....Carl Yastrzemski
1976….AL…...1B…...George Scott….....George Scott
1977….AL…...1B…...Jim Spencer…......Jason Thompson
1978….AL…...1B…...Chris Chambliss…..Chris Chambliss
1979….AL…...1B…...Cecil Cooper….....Eddie Murray
1980….AL…...1B…...Cecil Cooper….....Bruce Bochte
1981….AL…...1B…...Mike Squires….....Eddie Murray
1982….AL…...1B…...Eddie Murray….....Eddie Murray
1983….AL…...1B…...Eddie Murray….....Eddie Murray
1984….AL…...1B…...Eddie Murray….....Pete O’Brien
1985….AL…...1B…...Don Mattingly…....Pete O’Brien
1986….AL…...1B…...Don Mattingly…....Don Mattingly
1987….AL…...1B…...Don Mattingly…....Pete O’Brien
1988….AL…...1B…...Don Mattingly…....Pete O’Brien
1989….AL…...1B…...Don Mattingly…....Nick Esasky
1990….AL…...1B…...Mark McGwire….....Rafael Palmeiro
1991….AL…...1B…...Don Mattingly…....Wally Joyner
1992….AL…...1B…...Don Mattingly…....John Olerud
1993….AL…...1B…...Don Mattingly…....Rafael Palmeiro
1994….AL…...1B…...Don Mattingly…....Rafael Palmeiro
1995….AL…...1B…...J.T. Snow…........Rafael Palmeiro
1996….AL…...1B…...J.T. Snow…........Tino Martinez
1997….AL…...1B…...Rafael Palmeiro…..Tino Martinez
1998….AL…...1B…...Rafael Palmeiro…..David Segui
1999….AL…...1B…...Rafael Palmeiro…..Tino Martinez
2000….AL…...1B…...John Olerud…......John Olerud
2001….AL…...1B…...Doug Mientkiewicz.. Tino Martinez
2002….AL…...1B…...John Olerud…......John Olerud
2003….AL…...1B…...John Olerud…......John Olerud
1961….NL…...1B…...Bill White….......Gordy Coleman
1962….NL…...1B…...Bill White….......Orlando Cepeda
1963….NL…...1B…...Bill White….......Bill White
1964….NL…...1B…...Bill White….......Bill White
1965….NL…...1B…...Bill White….......Wes Parker
1966….NL…...1B…...Bill White….......Bill White
1967….NL…...1B…...Wes Parker….......Orlando Cepeda
1968….NL…...1B…...Wes Parker….......Donn Clendenon
1969….NL…...1B…...Wes Parker….......Joe Torre
1970….NL…...1B…...Wes Parker….......Wes Parker
1971….NL…...1B…...Wes Parker….......Nate Colbert
1972….NL…...1B…...Wes Parker….......Nate Colbert
1973….NL…...1B…...Mike Jorgensen…...Lee May
1974….NL…...1B…...Steve Garvey….....Steve Garvey
1975….NL…...1B…...Steve Garvey….....Steve Garvey
1976….NL…...1B…...Steve Garvey….....Steve Garvey
1977….NL…...1B…...Steve Garvey….....Steve Garvey
1978….NL…...1B…...Keith Hernandez…..Dan Driessen
1979….NL…...1B…...Keith Hernandez…..Bill Buckner
1980….NL…...1B…...Keith Hernandez…..Pete Rose
1981….NL…...1B…...Keith Hernandez…..Steve Garvey
1982….NL…...1B…...Keith Hernandez…..Steve Garvey
1983….NL…...1B…...Keith Hernandez…..Bill Buckner
1984….NL…...1B…...Keith Hernandez…..Steve Garvey
1985….NL…...1B…...Keith Hernandez…..Keith Hernandez
1986….NL…...1B…...Keith Hernandez…..Glenn Davis
1987….NL…...1B…...Keith Hernandez…..Andres Galarraga
1988….NL…...1B…...Keith Hernandez…..Glenn Davis
1989….NL…...1B…...Andres Galarraga….Eddie Murray
1990….NL…...1B…...Andres Galarraga….Mark Grace
1991….NL…...1B…...Will Clark….......Mark Grace
1992….NL…...1B…...Mark Grace….......Mark Grace
1993….NL…...1B…...Mark Grace….......Jeff Bagwell
1994….NL…...1B…...Jeff Bagwell….....Hal Morris
1995….NL…...1B…...Mark Grace….......Fred McGriff
1996….NL…...1B…...Mark Grace….......Eric Karros
1997….NL…...1B…...J.T. Snow…........Mark Grace
1998….NL…...1B…...J.T. Snow…........John Olerud
1999….NL…...1B…...J.T. Snow…........John Olerud
2000….NL…...1B…...J.T. Snow…........Todd Helton
2001….NL…...1B…...Todd Helton…......Todd Helton
2002….NL…...1B…...Todd Helton…......Eric Karros
2003….NL…...1B…...Derrek Lee….......Derrek Lee
1961….AL…...2B…...Bobby Richardson….Chuck Schilling
1962….AL…...2B…...Bobby Richardson….Jerry Kindall
1963….AL…...2B…...Bobby Richardson….Bobby Richardson
1964….AL…...2B…...Bobby Richardson….Jerry Adair
1965….AL…...2B…...Bobby Richardson….Jerry Adair
1966….AL…...2B…...Bobby Knoop…......Bobby Knoop
1967….AL…...2B…...Bobby Knoop…......Horace Clarke
1968….AL…...2B…...Bobby Knoop…......Horace Clarke
1969….AL…...2B…...Davey Johnson…....Horace Clarke
1970….AL…...2B…...Davey Johnson…....Davey Johnson
1971….AL…...2B…...Davey Johnson…....Dick Green
1972….AL…...2B…...Doug Griffin….....Jack Brohamer
1973….AL…...2B…...Bobby Grich…......Bobby Grich
1974….AL…...2B…...Bobby Grich…......Bobby Grich
1975….AL…...2B…...Bobby Grich…......Bobby Grich
1976….AL…...2B…...Bobby Grich…......Bobby Grich
1977….AL…...2B…...Frank White…......Bump Wills
1978….AL…...2B…...Frank White…......Bump Wills
1979….AL…...2B…...Frank White…......Willie Randolph
1980….AL…...2B…...Frank White…......Damaso Garcia
1981….AL…...2B…...Frank White…......Lou Whitaker
1982….AL…...2B…...Frank White…......Julio Cruz
1983….AL…...2B…...Lou Whitaker….....Frank White
1984….AL…...2B…...Lou Whitaker….....Willie Randolph
1985….AL…...2B…...Lou Whitaker….....Willie Randolph
1986….AL…...2B…...Frank White…......Frank White
1987….AL…...2B…...Frank White…......Frank White
1988….AL…...2B…...Harold Reynolds…..Frank White
1989….AL…...2B…...Harold Reynolds…..Frank White
1990….AL…...2B…...Harold Reynolds…..Jody Reed
1991….AL…...2B…...Roberto Alomar…...Harold Reynolds
1992….AL…...2B…...Roberto Alomar…...Jody Reed
1993….AL…...2B…...Roberto Alomar…...Scott Fletcher
1994….AL…...2B…...Roberto Alomar…...Jody Reed
1995….AL…...2B…...Roberto Alomar…...Carlos Baerga
1996….AL…...2B…...Roberto Alomar…...Roberto Alomar
1997….AL…...2B…...Chuck Knoblauch…..Roberto Alomar
1998….AL…...2B…...Roberto Alomar…...Chuck Knoblauch
1999….AL…...2B…...Roberto Alomar…...Roberto Alomar
2000….AL…...2B…...Roberto Alomar…...Randy Velarde
2001….AL…...2B…...Roberto Alomar…...Ray Durham
2002….AL…...2B…...Bret Boone….......Bret Boone
2003….AL…...2B…...Bret Boone….......Orlando Hudson
1961….NL…...2B…...Bill Mazeroski…...Bill Mazeroski
1962….NL…...2B…...Ken Hubbs…........Bill Mazeroski
1963….NL…...2B…...Bill Mazeroski…...Bill Mazeroski
1964….NL…...2B…...Bill Mazeroski…...Bill Mazeroski
1965….NL…...2B…...Bill Mazeroski…...Bill Mazeroski
1966….NL…...2B…...Bill Mazeroski…...Bill Mazeroski
1967….NL…...2B…...Bill Mazeroski…...Tito Fuentes
1968….NL…...2B…...Glenn Beckert…....Felix Millan
1969….NL…...2B…...Felix Millan….....Felix Millan
1970….NL…...2B…...Tommy Helms…......Tommy Helms
1971….NL…...2B…...Tommy Helms…......Felix Millan
1972….NL…...2B…...Felix Millan….....Dave Cash
1973….NL…...2B…...Joe Morgan….......Felix Millan
1974….NL…...2B…...Joe Morgan….......Ted Sizemore
1975….NL…...2B…...Joe Morgan….......Rennie Stennett
1976….NL…...2B…...Joe Morgan….......Manny Trillo
1977….NL…...2B…...Joe Morgan….......Davey Lopes
1978….NL…...2B…...Davey Lopes…......Manny Trillo
1979….NL…...2B…...Manny Trillo….....Ted Sizemore
1980….NL…...2B…...Doug Flynn….......Manny Trillo
1981….NL…...2B…...Manny Trillo….....Tom Herr
1982….NL…...2B…...Manny Trillo….....Glenn Hubbard
1983….NL…...2B…...Ryne Sandberg…....Johnny Ray
1984….NL…...2B…...Ryne Sandberg…....Ryne Sandberg
1985….NL…...2B…...Ryne Sandberg…....Glenn Hubbard
1986….NL…...2B…...Ryne Sandberg…....Ron Oester
1987….NL…...2B…...Ryne Sandberg…....Bill Doran
1988….NL…...2B…...Ryne Sandberg…....Jose Lind
1989….NL…...2B…...Ryne Sandberg…....Jose Oquendo
1990….NL…...2B…...Ryne Sandberg…....Jose Lind
1991….NL…...2B…...Ryne Sandberg…....Ryne Sandberg
1992….NL…...2B…...Jose Lind…........Ryne Sandberg
1993….NL…...2B…...Robby Thompson…...Mark Lemke
1994….NL…...2B…...Craig Biggio….....Mark Lemke
1995….NL…...2B…...Craig Biggio….....Mark Lemke
1996….NL…...2B…...Craig Biggio….....Mark Lemke
1997….NL…...2B…...Craig Biggio….....Craig Biggio
1998….NL…...2B…...Bret Boone….......Fernando Vina
1999….NL…...2B…...Pokey Reese…......Craig Biggio
2000….NL…...2B…...Pokey Reese…......Jeff Kent
2001….NL…...2B…...Fernando Vina…....Fernando Vina
2002….NL…...2B…...Fernando Vina…....Jose Vidro
2003….NL…...2B…...Luis Castillo…....Alex Cora
1961….AL…...SS…...Luis Aparicio…....Tony Kubek
1962….AL…...SS…...Luis Aparicio…....Zoilo Versailles
1963….AL…...SS…...Zoilo Versalles…..Ron Hansen
1964….AL…...SS…...Luis Aparicio…....Ron Hansen
1965….AL…...SS…...Zoilo Versalles…..Luis Aparicio
1966….AL…...SS…...Luis Aparicio…....Jim Fregosi
1967….AL…...SS…...Jim Fregosi…......Rico Petrocelli
1968….AL…...SS…...Luis Aparicio…....Bert Campaneris
1969….AL…...SS…...Mark Belanger…....Leo Cardenas
1970….AL…...SS…...Luis Aparicio…....Leo Cardenas
1971….AL…...SS…...Mark Belanger…....Mark Belanger
1972….AL…...SS…...Ed Brinkman…......Bert Campaneris
1973….AL…...SS…...Mark Belanger…....Freddie Patek
1974….AL…...SS…...Mark Belanger…....Bucky Dent
1975….AL…...SS…...Mark Belanger…....Bucky Dent
1976….AL…...SS…...Mark Belanger…....Mark Belanger
1977….AL…...SS…...Mark Belanger…....Rick Burleson
1978….AL…...SS…...Mark Belanger…....Rick Burleson
1979….AL…...SS…...Rick Burleson…....Rick Burleson
1980….AL…...SS…...Alan Trammell…....Rick Burleson
1981….AL…...SS…...Alan Trammell…....Alan Trammell
1982….AL…...SS…...Robin Yount…......Alfredo Griffen
1983….AL…...SS…...Alan Trammell…....Cal Ripken Jr.
1984….AL…...SS…...Alan Trammell…....Cal Ripken Jr.
1985….AL…...SS…...Alfredo Griffin…..Tony Fernandez
1986….AL…...SS…...Tony Fernandez…...Cal Ripken Jr.
1987….AL…...SS…...Tony Fernandez…...Greg Gagne
1988….AL…...SS…...Tony Fernandez…...Walt Weiss
1989….AL…...SS…...Tony Fernandez…...Cal Ripken Jr.
1990….AL…...SS…...Ozzie Guillen…....Ozzie Guillen
1991….AL…...SS…...Cal Ripken Jr…....Omar Vizquel
1992….AL…...SS…...Cal Ripken Jr…....Greg Gagne
1993….AL…...SS…...Omar Vizquel….....Omar Vizquel
1994….AL…...SS…...Omar Vizquel….....Cal Ripken Jr.
1995….AL…...SS…...Omar Vizquel….....Omar Vizquel
1996….AL…...SS…...Omar Vizquel….....Alex S. Gonzalez
1997….AL…...SS…...Omar Vizquel….....Jay Bell
1998….AL…...SS…...Omar Vizquel….....Alex S. Gonzalez
1999….AL…...SS…...Omar Vizquel….....Mike Bordick
2000….AL…...SS…...Omar Vizquel….....Alex Rodriguez
2001….AL…...SS…...Omar Vizquel….....Alex S. Gonzalez
2002….AL…...SS…...Alex Rodriguez…...Cristian Guzman
2003….AL…...SS…...Alex Rodriguez…...Jose Valentin
1961….NL…...SS…...Maury Wills…......Maury Wills
1962….NL…...SS…...Maury Wills…......Dick Groat
1963….NL…...SS…...Bobby Wine….......Dick Groat
1964….NL…...SS…...Ruben Amaro…......Leo Cardenas
1965….NL…...SS…...Leo Cardenas….....Maury Wills
1966….NL…...SS…...Gene Alley….......Leo Cardenas
1967….NL…...SS…...Gene Alley….......Dal Maxvill
1968….NL…...SS…...Dal Maxvill…......Dal Maxvill
1969….NL…...SS…...Don Kessinger…....Dal Maxvill
1970….NL…...SS…...Don Kessinger…....Bobby Wine
1971….NL…...SS…...Bud Harrelson…....Bud Harrelson
1972….NL…...SS…...Larry Bowa….......Larry Bowa
1973….NL…...SS…...Roger Metzger…....Bill Russell
1974….NL…...SS…...Dave Concepcion…..Dave Concepcion
1975….NL…...SS…...Dave Concepcion…..Dave Concepcion
1976….NL…...SS…...Dave Concepcion…..Dave Concepcion
1977….NL…...SS…...Dave Concepcion…..Dave Concepcion
1978….NL…...SS…...Larry Bowa….......Ozzie Smith
1979….NL…...SS…...Dave Concepcion…..Dave Concepcion
1980….NL…...SS…...Ozzie Smith…......Ozzie Smith
1981….NL…...SS…...Ozzie Smith…......Ozzie Smith
1982….NL…...SS…...Ozzie Smith…......Ozzie Smith
1983….NL…...SS…...Ozzie Smith…......Dale Berra
1984….NL…...SS…...Ozzie Smith…......Ozzie Smith
1985….NL…...SS…...Ozzie Smith…......Ozzie Smith
1986….NL…...SS…...Ozzie Smith…......Ozzie Smith
1987….NL…...SS…...Ozzie Smith…......Ozzie Smith
1988….NL…...SS…...Ozzie Smith…......Ozzie Smith
1989….NL…...SS…...Ozzie Smith…......Kevin Elster
1990….NL…...SS…...Ozzie Smith…......Barry Larkin
1991….NL…...SS…...Ozzie Smith…......Barry Larkin
1992….NL…...SS…...Ozzie Smith…......Ozzie Smith
1993….NL…...SS…...Jay Bell….........Jay Bell
1994….NL…...SS…...Barry Larkin….....Jay Bell
1995….NL…...SS…...Barry Larkin….....Kevin Stocker
1996….NL…...SS…...Barry Larkin….....Greg Gagne
1997….NL…...SS…...Rey Ordonez…......Royce Clayton
1998….NL…...SS…...Rey Ordonez…......Neifi Perez
1999….NL…...SS…...Rey Ordonez…......Rey Ordonez
2000….NL…...SS…...Neifi Perez…......Neifi Perez
2001….NL…...SS…...Orlando Cabrera…..Orlando Cabrera
2002….NL…...SS…...Edgar Renteria…...Juan Uribe
2003….NL…...SS…...Edgar Renteria…...Cesar Izturis
1961….AL…...3B…...Brooks Robinson…..Clete Boyer
1962….AL…...3B…...Brooks Robinson…..Clete Boyer
1963….AL…...3B…...Brooks Robinson…..Brooks Robinson
1964….AL…...3B…...Brooks Robinson…..Brooks Robinson
1965….AL…...3B…...Brooks Robinson…..Clete Boyer
1966….AL…...3B…...Brooks Robinson…..Max Alvis
1967….AL…...3B…...Brooks Robinson…..Brooks Robinson
1968….AL…...3B…...Brooks Robinson…..Brooks Robinson
1969….AL…...3B…...Brooks Robinson…..Brooks Robinson
1970….AL…...3B…...Brooks Robinson…..Graig Nettles
1971….AL…...3B…...Brooks Robinson…..Graig Nettles
1972….AL…...3B…...Brooks Robinson…..Graig Nettles
1973….AL…...3B…...Brooks Robinson…..Graig Nettles
1974….AL…...3B…...Brooks Robinson…..Aurelio Rodriguez
1975….AL…...3B…...Brooks Robinson…..Graig Nettles
1976….AL…...3B…...Aurelio Rodriguez.. Graig Nettles
1977….AL…...3B…...Graig Nettles…....George Brett
1978….AL…...3B…...Graig Nettles…....Graig Nettles
1979….AL…...3B…...Buddy Bell….......Buddy Bell
1980….AL…...3B…...Buddy Bell….......Doug DeCinces
1981….AL…...3B…...Buddy Bell….......John Castino
1982….AL…...3B…...Buddy Bell….......Buddy Bell
1983….AL…...3B…...Buddy Bell….......Gary Gaetti
1984….AL…...3B…...Buddy Bell….......Wade Boggs
1985….AL…...3B…...George Brett….....Gary Gaetti
1986….AL…...3B…...Gary Gaetti…......Gary Gaetti
1987….AL…...3B…...Gary Gaetti…......Gary Gaetti
1988….AL…...3B…...Gary Gaetti…......Kelly Gruber
1989….AL…...3B…...Gary Gaetti…......Jack Howell
1990….AL…...3B…...Kelly Gruber….....Gary Gaetti
1991….AL…...3B…...Robin Ventura…....Mike Pagliarulo
1992….AL…...3B…...Robin Ventura…....Robin Ventura
1993….AL…...3B…...Robin Ventura…....Wade Boggs
1994….AL…...3B…...Wade Boggs….......Robin Ventura
1995….AL…...3B…...Wade Boggs….......Travis Fryman
1996….AL…...3B…...Robin Ventura…....Robin Ventura
1997….AL…...3B…...Matt Williams…....Jeff Cirillo
1998….AL…...3B…...Robin Ventura…....John Valentin
1999….AL…...3B…...Scott Brosius…....Scott Brosius
2000….AL…...3B…...Travis Fryman…....Tony Batista
2001….AL…...3B…...Eric Chavez…......Eric Chavez
2002….AL…...3B…...Eric Chavez…......Corey Koskie
2003….AL…...3B…...Eric Chavez…......Eric Chavez
1961….NL…...3B…...Ken Boyer…........Ken Boyer
1962….NL…...3B…...Jim Davenport…....Ken Boyer
1963….NL…...3B…...Ken Boyer…........Ron Santo
1964….NL…...3B…...Ron Santo…........Ron Santo
1965….NL…...3B…...Ron Santo…........Ron Santo
1966….NL…...3B…...Ron Santo…........Ron Santo
1967….NL…...3B…...Ron Santo…........Ron Santo
1968….NL…...3B…...Ron Santo…........Ron Santo
1969….NL…...3B…...Clete Boyer…......Doug Rader
1970….NL…...3B…...Doug Rader….......Doug Rader
1971….NL…...3B…...Doug Rader….......Ron Santo
1972….NL…...3B…...Doug Rader….......Doug Rader
1973….NL…...3B…...Doug Rader….......Darrell Evans
1974….NL…...3B…...Doug Rader….......Mike Schmidt
1975….NL…...3B…...Ken Reitz…........Darrell Evans
1976….NL…...3B…...Mike Schmidt….....Mike Schmidt
1977….NL…...3B…...Mike Schmidt….....Mike Schmidt
1978….NL…...3B…...Mike Schmidt….....Darrell Evans
1979….NL…...3B…...Mike Schmidt….....Mike Schmidt
1980….NL…...3B…...Mike Schmidt….....Mike Schmidt
1981….NL…...3B…...Mike Schmidt….....Art Howe
1982….NL…...3B…...Mike Schmidt….....Tim Wallach
1983….NL…...3B…...Mike Schmidt….....Mike Schmidt
1984….NL…...3B…...Mike Schmidt….....Tim Wallach
1985….NL…...3B…...Tim Wallach…......Tim Wallach
1986….NL…...3B…...Mike Schmidt….....Terry Pendleton
1987….NL…...3B…...Terry Pendleton…..Tim Wallach
1988….NL…...3B…...Tim Wallach…......Tim Wallach
1989….NL…...3B…...Terry Pendleton…..Ken Caminiti
1990….NL…...3B…...Tim Wallach…......Tim Wallach
1991….NL…...3B…...Matt Williams…....Terry Pendleton
1992….NL…...3B…...Terry Pendleton…..Terry Pendleton
1993….NL…...3B…...Matt Williams…....Terry Pendleton
1994….NL…...3B…...Matt Williams…....Matt Williams
1995….NL…...3B…...Ken Caminiti….....Charlie Hayes
1996….NL…...3B…...Ken Caminiti….....Vinny Castilla
1997….NL…...3B…...Ken Caminiti….....Scott Rolen
1998….NL…...3B…...Scott Rolen…......Jeff Cirillo
1999….NL…...3B…...Robin Ventura…....Robin Ventura
2000….NL…...3B…...Scott Rolen…......Jeff Cirillo
2001….NL…...3B…...Scott Rolen…......Scott Rolen
2002….NL…...3B…...Scott Rolen…......Aaron Boone
2003….NL…...3B…...Scott Rolen…......Adrian Beltre
1961….AL…...OF…...Al Kaline…........Bill Bruton
1961….AL…...OF…...Jim Landis….......Jackie Brandt
1961….AL…...OF…...Jim Piersall….....Mickey Mantle
1962….AL…...OF…...Al Kaline…........Albie Pearson
1962….AL…...OF…...Jim Landis….......Bill Bruton
1962….AL…...OF…...Mickey Mantle…....Lenny Green
1963….AL…...OF…...Al Kaline…........Albie Pearson
1963….AL…...OF…...Carl Yastrzemski….Carl Yastrzemski
1963….AL…...OF…...Jim Landis….......Tom Tresh
1964….AL…...OF…...Al Kaline…........Jackie Brandt
1964….AL…...OF…...Jim Landis….......Jimmie Hall
1964….AL…...OF…...Vic Davalillo…....Mike Hershberger
1965….AL…...OF…...Al Kaline…........Jimmie Hall
1965….AL…...OF…...Carl Yastrzemski….Jose Cardenal
1965….AL…...OF…...Tom Tresh…........Ken Berry
1966….AL…...OF…...Al Kaline…........Ted Uhlaender
1966….AL…...OF…...Tommie Agee…......Tommie Agee
1966….AL…...OF…...Tony Oliva….......Tony Oliva
1967….AL…...OF…...Al Kaline…........Paul Blair
1967….AL…...OF…...Carl Yastrzemski….Reggie Smith
1967….AL…...OF…...Paul Blair….......Tommie Agee
1968….AL…...OF…...Carl Yastrzemski….Jose Cardenal
1968….AL…...OF…...Mickey Stanley…...Mickey Stanley
1968….AL…...OF…...Reggie Smith….....Reggie Smith
1969….AL…...OF…...Carl Yastrzemski….Jim Northrup
1969….AL…...OF…...Mickey Stanley…...Lou Piniella
1969….AL…...OF…...Paul Blair….......Paul Blair
1970….AL…...OF…...Ken Berry…........Amos Otis
1970….AL…...OF…...Mickey Stanley…...Reggie Smith
1970….AL…...OF…...Paul Blair….......Paul Blair
1971….AL…...OF…...Amos Otis…........Amos Otis
1971….AL…...OF…...Carl Yastrzemski….Dave May
1971….AL…...OF…...Paul Blair….......Paul Blair
1972….AL…...OF…...Bobby Murcer….....Bobby Darwin
1972….AL…...OF…...Ken Berry…........Cesar Tovar
1972….AL…...OF…...Paul Blair….......Paul Blair
1973….AL…...OF…...Amos Otis…........Bill North
1973….AL…...OF…...Mickey Stanley…...Mickey Stanley
1973….AL…...OF…...Paul Blair….......Paul Blair
1974….AL…...OF…...Amos Otis…........Amos Otis
1974….AL…...OF…...Joe Rudi….........Bill North
1974….AL…...OF…...Paul Blair….......Paul Blair
1975….AL…...OF…...Fred Lynn…........Bill North
1975….AL…...OF…...Joe Rudi….........Fred Lynn
1975….AL…...OF…...Paul Blair….......Ken Henderson
1976….AL…...OF…...Dwight Evans….....Juan Beniquez
1976….AL…...OF…...Joe Rudi….........Mickey Rivers
1976….AL…...OF…...Rick Manning….....Ron LeFlore
1977….AL…...OF…...Al Cowens…........Amos Otis
1977….AL…...OF…...Carl Yastrzemski….Chet Lemon
1977….AL…...OF…...Juan Beniquez…....Mickey Rivers
1978….AL…...OF…...Dwight Evans….....Amos Otis
1978….AL…...OF…...Fred Lynn…........Fred Lynn
1978….AL…...OF…...Rick Miller…......Mickey Rivers
1979….AL…...OF…...Dwight Evans….....Chet Lemon
1979….AL…...OF…...Fred Lynn…........Fred Lynn
1979….AL…...OF…...Sixto Lezcano…....Rick Bosetti
1980….AL…...OF…...Dwayne Murphy…....Dwayne Murphy
1980….AL…...OF…...Fred Lynn…........Rickey Henderson
1980….AL…...OF…...Willie Wilson…....Willie Wilson
1981….AL…...OF…...Dwayne Murphy…....Dwayne Murphy
1981….AL…...OF…...Dwight Evans….....Willie Wilson
1981….AL…...OF…...Rickey Henderson….Rickey Henderson
1982….AL…...OF…...Dave Winfield…....Al Bumbry
1982….AL…...OF…...Dwayne Murphy…....Lloyd Moseby
1982….AL…...OF…...Dwight Evans….....Willie Wilson
1983….AL…...OF…...Dave Winfield…....Chet Lemon
1983….AL…...OF…...Dwayne Murphy…....George Wright
1983….AL…...OF…...Dwight Evans….....Lloyd Moseby
1984….AL…...OF…...Dave Winfield…....Kirby Puckett
1984….AL…...OF…...Dwayne Murphy…....Lloyd Moseby
1984….AL…...OF…...Dwight Evans….....Willie Wilson
1985….AL…...OF…...Dave Winfield…....Jesse Barfield
1985….AL…...OF…...Dwayne Murphy…....Kirby Puckett
1985….AL…...OF…...Dwight Evans….....Lloyd Moseby
1985….AL…...OF…...Gary Pettis
1986….AL…...OF…...Gary Pettis…......Gary Pettis
1986….AL…...OF…...Jesse Barfield…...Rickey Henderson
1986….AL…...OF…...Kirby Puckett…....Willie Wilson
1987….AL…...OF…...Dave Winfield…....Jesse Barfield
1987….AL…...OF…...Jesse Barfield…...Ken Williams
1987….AL…...OF…...Kirby Puckett…....Willie Wilson
1988….AL…...OF…...Devon White…......Joe Carter
1988….AL…...OF…...Gary Pettis…......Robin Yount
1988….AL…...OF…...Kirby Puckett…....Kirby Puckett
1989….AL…...OF…...Devon White…......Devon White
1989….AL…...OF…...Gary Pettis…......Dave Henderson
1989….AL…...OF…...Kirby Puckett…....Kirby Puckett
1990….AL…...OF…...Ellis Burks…......Dave Henderson
1990….AL…...OF…...Gary Pettis…......Lance Johnson
1990….AL…...OF…...Ken Griffey Jr…...Roberto Kelly
1991….AL…...OF…...Devon White…......Devon White
1991….AL…...OF…...Ken Griffey Jr…...Lance Johnson
1991….AL…...OF…...Kirby Puckett…....Kirby Puckett
1992….AL…...OF…...Devon White…......Devon White
1992….AL…...OF…...Ken Griffey Jr…...Brian McRae
1992….AL…...OF…...Kirby Puckett…....Kirby Puckett
1993….AL…...OF…...Devon White…......Brian McRae
1993….AL…...OF…...Ken Griffey Jr…...Chad Curtis
1993….AL…...OF…...Kenny Lofton….....Lance Johnson
1994….AL…...OF…...Devon White…......Brian McRae
1994….AL…...OF…...Ken Griffey Jr…...Lance Johnson
1994….AL…...OF…...Kenny Lofton….....Turner Ward
1995….AL…...OF…...Devon White…......Albert Belle
1995….AL…...OF…...Ken Griffey Jr…...Bernie Williams
1995….AL…...OF…...Kenny Lofton….....Jim Edmonds
1996….AL…...OF…...Jay Buhner….......Bernie Williams
1996….AL…...OF…...Ken Griffey Jr…...Rich Becker
1996….AL…...OF…...Kenny Lofton….....Kenny Lofton
1997….AL…...OF…...Bernie Williams…..Brian L. Hunter
1997….AL…...OF…...Jim Edmonds…......Gerald Williams
1997….AL…...OF…...Ken Griffey Jr…...Ken Griffey Jr.
1998….AL…...OF…...Bernie Williams…..Darren Lewis
1998….AL…...OF…...Jim Edmonds…......Jim Edmonds
1998….AL…...OF…...Ken Griffey Jr…...Kenny Lofton
1999….AL…...OF…...Bernie Williams…..Bernie Williams
1999….AL…...OF…...Ken Griffey Jr…...Darren Lewis
1999….AL…...OF…...Shawn Green…......Garret Anderson
2000….AL…...OF…...Bernie Williams…..Bernie Williams
2000….AL…...OF…...Darin Erstad….....Carl Everett
2000….AL…...OF…...Jermaine Dye….....Chris Singleton
2001….AL…...OF…...Ichiro Suzuki…....Darin Erstad
2001….AL…...OF…...Mike Cameron….....Mike Cameron
2001….AL…...OF…...Torii Hunter….....Torii Hunter
2002….AL…...OF…...Darin Erstad….....Darin Erstad
2002….AL…...OF…...Ichiro Suzuki…....Carlos Beltran
2002….AL…...OF…...Torii Hunter….....Terrence Long
2003….AL…...OF…...Mike Cameron….....Mike Cameron
2003….AL…...OF…...Ichiro Suzuki…....Carlos Beltran
2003….AL…...OF…...Torii Hunter….....Torii Hunter
1961….NL…...OF…...Roberto Clemente….Frank Robinson
1961….NL…...OF…...Vada Pinson…......Vada Pinson
1961….NL…...OF…...Willie Mays…......Hank Aaron
1962….NL…...OF…...Bill Virdon…......Bill Virdon
1962….NL…...OF…...Roberto Clemente….Curt Flood
1962….NL…...OF…...Willie Mays…......Willie Mays
1963….NL…...OF…...Curt Flood….......Curt Flood
1963….NL…...OF…...Roberto Clemente….Johnny Callison
1963….NL…...OF…...Willie Mays…......Willie Davis
1964….NL…...OF…...Curt Flood….......Curt Flood
1964….NL…...OF…...Roberto Clemente….Willie Davis
1964….NL…...OF…...Willie Mays…......Willie Mays
1965….NL…...OF…...Curt Flood….......Willie Davis
1965….NL…...OF…...Roberto Clemente….Roberto Clemente
1965….NL…...OF…...Willie Mays…......Willie Mays
1966….NL…...OF…...Curt Flood….......Curt Flood
1966….NL…...OF…...Roberto Clemente….Willie Davis
1966….NL…...OF…...Willie Mays…......Willie Mays
1967….NL…...OF…...Curt Flood….......Adolfo Phillips
1967….NL…...OF…...Roberto Clemente….Vada Pinson
1967….NL…...OF…...Willie Mays…......Willie Mays
1968….NL…...OF…...Curt Flood….......Curt Flood
1968….NL…...OF…...Roberto Clemente….Roberto Clemente
1968….NL…...OF…...Willie Mays…......Adolfo Phillips
1969….NL…...OF…...Curt Flood….......Curt Flood
1969….NL…...OF…...Pete Rose…........Bobby Bonds
1969….NL…...OF…...Roberto Clemente….Tommie Agee
1970….NL…...OF…...Pete Rose…........Pete Rose
1970….NL…...OF…...Roberto Clemente….Bobby Tolan
1970….NL…...OF…...Tommie Agee…......Tommie Agee
1971….NL…...OF…...Bobby Bonds…......Bobby Bonds
1971….NL…...OF…...Roberto Clemente….George Foster
1971….NL…...OF…...Willie Davis….....Willie Davis
1972….NL…...OF…...Cesar Cedeno….....Al Oliver
1972….NL…...OF…...Roberto Clemente….Rick Monday
1972….NL…...OF…...Willie Davis….....Willie Davis
1973….NL…...OF…...Bobby Bonds…......Dusty Baker
1973….NL…...OF…...Cesar Cedeno….....Garry Maddox
1973….NL…...OF…...Willie Davis….....Willie Davis
1974….NL…...OF…...Bobby Bonds…......Bake McBride
1974….NL…...OF…...Cesar Cedeno….....Cesar Cedeno
1974….NL…...OF…...Cesar Geronimo…...Jimmy Wynn
1975….NL…...OF…...Cesar Cedeno….....Al Oliver
1975….NL…...OF…...Cesar Geronimo…...Cesar Geronimo
1975….NL…...OF…...Garry Maddox….....Garry Maddox
1976….NL…...OF…...Cesar Cedeno….....Al Oliver
1976….NL…...OF…...Cesar Geronimo…...Bill Buckner
1976….NL…...OF…...Garry Maddox….....Garry Maddox
1977….NL…...OF…...Cesar Geronimo…...Cesar Cedeno
1977….NL…...OF…...Dave Parker…......Dave Parker
1977….NL…...OF…...Garry Maddox….....Omar Moreno
1978….NL…...OF…...Dave Parker…......Andre Dawson
1978….NL…...OF…...Ellis Valentine…..Garry Maddox
1978….NL…...OF…...Garry Maddox….....Omar Moreno
1979….NL…...OF…...Dave Parker…......Andre Dawson
1979….NL…...OF…...Dave Winfield…....Omar Moreno
1979….NL…...OF…...Garry Maddox….....Tony Scott
1980….NL…...OF…...Andre Dawson….....Dale Murphy
1980….NL…...OF…...Dave Winfield…....Omar Moreno
1980….NL…...OF…...Garry Maddox….....Garry Maddox
1981….NL…...OF…...Andre Dawson….....Andre Dawson
1981….NL…...OF…...Dusty Baker…......Ken Griffey Sr.
1981….NL…...OF…...Garry Maddox….....Tony Scott
1982….NL…...OF…...Andre Dawson….....Andre Dawson
1982….NL…...OF…...Dale Murphy…......Omar Moreno
1982….NL…...OF…...Garry Maddox….....Ruppert Jones
1983….NL…...OF…...Andre Dawson….....Andre Dawson
1983….NL…...OF…...Dale Murphy…......Eddie Milner
1983….NL…...OF…...Willie McGee….....Mookie Wilson
1984….NL…...OF…...Andre Dawson….....Dale Murphy
1984….NL…...OF…...Bob Dernier…......Kevin McReynolds
1984….NL…...OF…...Dale Murphy…......Tim Raines
1985….NL…...OF…...Andre Dawson….....Eddie Milner
1985….NL…...OF…...Dale Murphy…......Kevin McReynolds
1985….NL…...OF…...Willie McGee….....Willie McGee
1986….NL…...OF…...Dale Murphy…......Kevin Bass
1986….NL…...OF…...Tony Gwynn….......Mitch Webster
1986….NL…...OF…...Willie McGee….....Willie McGee
1987….NL…...OF…...Andre Dawson….....Andy Van Slyke
1987….NL…...OF…...Eric Davis….......Barry Bonds
1987….NL…...OF…...Tony Gwynn….......Milt Thompson
1988….NL…...OF…...Andre Dawson….....Gerald Young
1988….NL…...OF…...Andy Van Slyke…...Andy Van Slyke
1988….NL…...OF…...Eric Davis….......John Shelby
1989….NL…...OF…...Andy Van Slyke…...Gerald Young
1989….NL…...OF…...Eric Davis….......Milt Thompson
1989….NL…...OF…...Tony Gwynn….......Tony Gwynn
1990….NL…...OF…...Andy Van Slyke…...Billy Hatcher
1990….NL…...OF…...Barry Bonds…......Joe Carter
1990….NL…...OF…...Tony Gwynn….......Lenny Dykstra
1991….NL…...OF…...Andy Van Slyke…...Brett Butler
1991….NL…...OF…...Barry Bonds…......Marquis Grissom
1991….NL…...OF…...Tony Gwynn….......Ron Gant
1992….NL…...OF…...Andy Van Slyke…...Andy Van Slyke
1992….NL…...OF…...Barry Bonds…......Darrin Jackson
1992….NL…...OF…...Larry Walker….....Marquis Grissom
1993….NL…...OF…...Barry Bonds…......Chuck Carr
1993….NL…...OF…...Larry Walker….....Otis Nixon
1993….NL…...OF…...Marquis Grissom…..Marquis Grissom
1994….NL…...OF…...Barry Bonds…......Chuck Carr
1994….NL…...OF…...Darren Lewis….....Roberto Kelly
1994….NL…...OF…...Marquis Grissom…..Marquis Grissom
1995….NL…...OF…...Marquis Grissom…..Marquis Grissom
1995….NL…...OF…...Raul Mondesi….....David Justice
1995….NL…...OF…...Steve Finley….....Brian McRae
1996….NL…...OF…...Barry Bonds…......F.P. Santangelo
1996….NL…...OF…...Marquis Grissom…..Marquis Grissom
1996….NL…...OF…...Steve Finley….....Ray Lankford
1997….NL…...OF…...Barry Bonds…......Andruw Jones
1997….NL…...OF…...Larry Walker….....Rondell White
1997….NL…...OF…...Raul Mondesi….....Raul Mondesi
1998….NL…...OF…...Andruw Jones….....Andruw Jones
1998….NL…...OF…...Barry Bonds…......Carl Everett
1998….NL…...OF…...Larry Walker….....Doug Glanville
1999….NL…...OF…...Andruw Jones….....Andruw Jones
1999….NL…...OF…...Larry Walker….....Mike Cameron
1999….NL…...OF…...Steve Finley….....Steve Finley
2000….NL…...OF…...Andruw Jones….....Andruw Jones
2000….NL…...OF…...Jim Edmonds…......Ken Griffey Jr.
2000….NL…...OF…...Steve Finley….....Tom Goodwin
2001….NL…...OF…...Andruw Jones….....Andruw Jones
2001….NL…...OF…...Jim Edmonds…......Doug Glanville
2001….NL…...OF…...Larry Walker….....Juan Pierre
2002….NL…...OF…...Andruw Jones….....Andruw Jones
2002….NL…...OF…...Jim Edmonds…......Juan Pierre
2002….NL…...OF…...Larry Walker….....Steve Finley
2003….NL…...OF…...Andruw Jones….....Andruw Jones
2003….NL…...OF…...Jim Edmonds…......Craig Biggio
2003….NL…...OF…...Jose Cruz Jr….....Jose Cruz Jr.



It’s interesting to see how different the actual gold glove winners are to the players with the most defensive win shares.  To me it shows even further how difficult it is to quantify defense.  Joe Morgan would never have won a gold glove by the win shares method and Ryne Sandberg and Roberto Alomar would only have won three each.  That just doesn’t quite seem right.  I like think that I like that the gold glove winners are based upon opinions rather than statistical formulas.

Posted by .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)  on  11/09  at  08:13 PM

While I agree that fielding statistics are not as conclusive as hitting or pitching stats, I also think this list serves as a warning for awards that are based entirely on subjectivity.

I’m not sure why you say that Alomar and Sandberg should have won more than three Gold Gloves, for instance.  What is that based on?

Conversely, I might point to Mark Lemke and ask why he never won a Gold Glove.

To me, the exciting thing is that fielding stats are finally evolving to the point at which they can meaningfully contribute to the Gold Glove debates.  There has been far too much subjectivity in this area in the past, IMO.

Posted by .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)  on  11/10  at  06:17 AM

Barry Bonds is regarded as a great defensive LF, but would never win a GG!!??  Well I guess some great players never won an MVP.

Posted by .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)  on  11/11  at  04:29 PM

Joe: Barry Bonds is regarded as a great defensive LF, but would never win a GG!!??  Well I guess some great players never won an MVP.

Corner outfielders never earn as many Win Shares as center fielders.

Posted by .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)  on  11/27  at  05:59 PM
Page 1 of 1 pages
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.
<<Previous Article:  NL Gold Gloves Next Article:  Bonds held back by own pitchers!>>